Dr. Cottingham was appointed Interim Upper School Director in July 2021, and her Pingry experience includes three years as Upper School Academic Dean and a semester as Interim English Department Chair.
Where Are They Now?
Discover the colleges and universities where our recent alumni are attending:
Click on each state to see where the previous five years' graduating classes have matriculated.
- District of Columbia
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New York
- North Carolina
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
It was spring of his junior year when they first met. Mrs. Cooperman listened carefully to Herb to understand his interests, academic and otherwise.
"I'm interested in studying business management, and she has definitely focused on schools that are known for being well-versed in business," he says. A member of Pingry's Baseball Team, Herb is also interested in pursuing baseball in college. Having worked with many student athletes in the past, Mrs. Cooperman was more than prepared to make suggestions for how he could broaden his search to include athletics.
She also helped him with his senior-year course selections, ensuring that he will be well positioned when it comes time to apply to colleges. "She makes sure you have enough rigor, but not so much that it will be too difficult, especially with the schedule of a student-athlete. For example, she wanted to make sure I took a precalculus class. And she helped me to decide between an honors class over a regular track class in another subject," he explains.
As his senior year approaches, what is Herb most looking forward to? "Seeing where all of the work I've put into this process so far gets me."
He feels reassured knowing that Mrs. Cooperman will be beside him every step of the way. "It helps with my confidence in what I'm doing," he says. "It's not just something my parents and I are working on. I now have an academic ally in the process."
"I already knew him as a person, but the college counseling role was so new to me. It was a new way for me to connect," recalls Ally.
Passionate about photography—she plans to take Honors Portfolio her senior year—and community service—she tutors Pingry Lower Schoolers as well as three fourth graders outside of school once a week—Ally had a good sense of a few colleges she wanted to explore, and felt fairly well prepared for her first meeting with him. But she wasn't expecting the level of guidance she received.
"I walked into his office that first day and he gave me so much information—all kinds of new admission strategies, tips for the ACT, he helped me form my class schedule for senior year, and he suggested a list of schools and ideas for identifying others," she says. "It was more comprehensive than I was anticipating."
She has found one approach of his to be particularly helpful: "He told me at the beginning to choose two schools a week that are completely different from each other, and research them a bit. Every week I email him an update about what I think of them," she explains. "He's been very communicative about talking through my responses and saying, 'Well, if you like that one, you should check out this one, too.'"
Ally is leaning towards early decision, but isn't yet certain. She's excited to spend the summer leading into her senior year looking at more schools, seeing where she will fit in, and whittling down her options, she says. No matter where she ends up, she knows that the man who sat next to her mom in high school chemistry class will help her to get there.
A few months after he arrived, he periodically checked in with Mrs. Cooperman, now his college counselor, to make sure he was setting himself up for the path he knew he wanted to pursue. "She was 100% helpful and able to give me guidance because has been through the process before with other students applying to military academies," he says.
She told him about two events in particular that she felt would be helpful. One was a virtual military academy fair, which he "attended" the fall of his junior year. "Senator Malinowski and Congressman Menendez both spoke—it gave me a really cool, in-depth view into the academies," he recalls. Mrs. Cooperman also told him about the West Point "Field Force" informational session, which was held remotely as well, the following spring. Due to the pandemic and the resulting changes to the application process, the procedures covered were especially useful, he says.
One of Big Blue's top wrestlers, Jack is also considering pursuing the sport he loves in college. Mrs. Cooperman, in addition to Mr. Lear, Dean of College Counseling and Director of Student Support Services, have been making suggestions on this front, too. "They have helped me figure out schools that would be a good fit, and how and when to reach out to coaches, for service academies as well as other schools," he says.
It's still early in the process, but Jack—who received the Dwight Dr. Eisenhower Leadership Award from the USMA Field Force and the West Point Society of New Jersey—says he feels confident that with the help of the Office of College Counseling, he'll end up where he's meant to. He has only to think back to the Zoom meetings he had last summer with Mrs. Cooperman to know he's in good hands. "That level of commitment to me has been really appreciated," he says. "Their personal sacrifice for the students has been amazing."
But when the inevitable conversations about "college stuff" do happen, she relies on Mr. Lear's feedback. "Being from Belgium, my family doesn't know a lot of colleges here. I've already learned about so many schools from him that I hadn't even considered. He has opened a lot of doors I didn't know about."
Last fall, he also suggested an ACT score to aim for. When she nailed it the following spring, she immediately wanted to share the exciting news with him. "I didn't get to see him during the day because I was so busy, so I emailed him. He wrote me right back and was so happy for me. It made me feel so nice. In some weird way, just the moral support of all the counselors makes you feel a lot better."
Dilan did end up tweaking his schedule, but the changes were judicious, reasoned, and personal. A varsity water polo player since his freshman year, he really wanted to give fencing a go his junior year, which, he says, ended up being one of his best decisions. "It's like an art. There's so much grace and strategy to it, and the connections I made on the team are invaluable." He loves the sciences and has doubled up on science classes the past three years, including Honors Physics and AP Chemistry. Feeling a bit less pressure his senior year, he's excited to branch out to AP Psychology, an in-depth English class on Shakespeare, and Creative Writing. Dilan also considered dropping Spanish, which he had taken for several years. Mr. Lear, offering gentle but persuasive guidance in his course selections, convinced him otherwise. "It surprised me that he didn't just say take this class or apply to this college. He doesn't just tell me what to do. He guides me through my options and opens up a discussion to let me decide."
Thanks to Mr. Lear, Dilan feels ready to take on the college admission process. "College applications have always been in the future, something to tackle later. Now, it's here! As a senior, there's a lot that's finally here. It's scary, but it's also exciting."
Natalie enjoys having a full schedule, which includes a fall and spring job at a local restaurant after school (in the winter, she's a member of the Varsity Ski Racing Team). It keeps her organized, she says. Mrs. Kinney, who has had experience in the restaurant industry herself, and also happens to have been one of Natalie's ski coaches, understands, and has a calming effect. "There's no way to describe her impact. If I were to leave Pingry and be asked what teacher impacted me the most, it would be Mrs. Kinney. She's so good about not just the academic part, but the 'I'm here for you part.'"
Asked to identify the single most helpful event or resource offered by the College Counseling Office, for Natalie, it's their annual College Case Study Night. Nearly a dozen deans and directors of admission from a range of colleges and universities across the U.S. gather on the Basking Ridge Campus with juniors and their parents to participate in eye-opening, mock admission committees—just one example of their many efforts to demystify the college application process, and make things personal. "The entire College Counseling team puts everything into perspective," she adds.
He has also appreciated being able to turn to any of the six other counselors in the office for feedback, including assistant football coach and counselor, Mr. Garrow, who he has gotten to know both on the field and off. With 20 years of experience coaching Division I ice hockey before arriving at Pingry, Mr. Garrow's perspective on college sports has been helpful to Patrick. "All the counselors are very well prepared and well organized, with a lot of experience," he says. "It's really easy to go to them and talk about what you want and what you need. They'll always have an answer for you, or they'll get back to you within an hour if they don't."
A rising senior and soon-to-be captain of the Varsity Football Team, Patrick is looking forward to the season—and school year—ahead. "I'm excited to get into college, to settle down and know what my next step will be."
Andrew appreciated their candor. And, as a Pingry lifer, he sees parallels to his school experience. “What has made my time at Pingry so rewarding is learning that it’s not always going to be easy. You have to put in the work to get the rewards. It’s figuring out how to apply the tools you’re learning—how to write a five-paragraph essay that’s better than the last one you wrote. Or how to write one that no one else has written,” he says, by way of example. “Everything here is so worth the effort.”
He admits that the college application process is a similar give and take. “The grill is turned up your senior year, but the College Counseling Office is very good at not being overbearing and making the process horrible,” he jokes. “Mrs. Finegan [his college counselor] underscores that it’s not the end of the world—it’s just a big part."
How will Andrew think about Pingry 30 years from now? “I will feel proud to have been a part of this class,” he says. “Maybe I’m saying that because I was elected by all of them! But, I really do enjoy the company of all my friends and classmates, and I’m excited to see what we all do in the future.”
Kevin has come to find calm and quiet in the pool—whether he’s stroking at top speed during a championship meet where everything is on the line, or shaking off pre-exam nerves. He finds the same sort of calm in Pingry’s College Counseling Office. “The counselors guide you through the process so you don’t feel as stressed. Their message is ‘We’ll help you get through it, you’re not on your own,’” he explains. “It definitely takes some of the burden off.” As a sophomore, he applied to a summer program at Wharton and remembers his counselor, Mrs. Reynolds, helping him step-by-step through the application process. “It was a great preview to the college application process. Any questions I had, she was always there to answer them,” he recalls.
With his senior year—and senior swim season—looming, Kevin admits to feeling a little nervous about the college process, and is undecided about what field most interests him. But, as with his senior swim campaign, he’s also very excited. He just returned from a month-long internship doing artificial intelligence work in China; up for grabs next winter is a twelfth straight state title for his team; and Mrs. Reynolds will be at his side throughout the year. Oh, and his mother was right. His asthma is cured.
Solape, a Big Blue basketball player and track & field athlete, is also wise to the bigger picture. It’s a mindset, she says, that her college counselor, Sue Kinney, who also happens to be her advisor, has helped to cultivate. “I’m always panicking, but Mrs. Kinney has this calming effect on me, like a mom. Sometimes I go in to her office just to say hello because I haven’t seen her in a week. The college application process has a big impact on your life. Where do I see myself for the next four years?! But she has helped me to know that I shouldn’t get too stressed.”
Also helpful, she says, are two annual events hosted by Pingry’s College Counseling Department and designed specifically for juniors. The first, a Case Study Night, has mock student/parent admission committees meet with actual college admission representatives to learn the inside scoop. The second, a College Jumpstart day shortly after the end of junior year, brings eight college admission representatives to campus to chat with students. “That was a huge help,” recalls Solape. “I got to understand what they’re thinking, I got a view on what to do and what not to do in the admission process. For example, don’t be a ‘try hard’—just be yourself and do what interests you.” It’s advice, one might argue, that Solape has already taken to heart.
An avid climber, Gabe had long wanted to visit Everest Base Camp in Nepal and El Chaltén in Argentina. Using those two destinations as focal points, he proceeded to design a year of remarkable travel and experience. Climbing Aconcagua (the tallest mountain in the Western Hemisphere); visiting Patagonia; working for two months at a hotel in El Chaltén, Argentina; volunteering for six weeks at Heaven Hill Academy, a school in a rural Nepalese village; and trekking the Annapurna Circuit were just a few of the experiences that followed (he ended up spending three months in Nepal and four in Argentina). From there, he visited Israel—Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, the Golan Heights, the Negev Desert, and the Dead Sea—and London, Amsterdam, Cophenhagen, Berlin, and Budapest, are on his itinerary this summer, all before he settles into college life as a freshman at Dartmouth. When his travels are complete, he estimates he will have spent 108 hours on planes, visited four continents and each of the four hemispheres, and eaten 124 meals during which he conversed only in Spanish.
"Over the past year, I’ve sacrificed chickens, eaten hallucinogenic honey, surfed the Chilean coast, and drank some of the world's finest wines. Even more memorable than those experiences are the countless friends I made from every corner of the globe," he says. "I list all of these experiences not to say, 'look at how interesting and well traveled I am,' but hopefully to demonstrate how many possibilities there are if you decide to take a gap year. For the first time in my life, I can honestly say that I have absolute confidence in my ability to adapt to, and even thrive in, almost every situation imaginable. I’d also like to add that, for the first time in a long time, I’m actually excited to go to school."
Her interests are numerous, to say the least. This fact is a boon at Pingry, which offers a club or experience to satisfy any curiosity, academic or otherwise. But, Ally admits, eclectic interests can be a bit of hindrance when trying to settle on a college. “I was having a hard time deciding whether or not to apply early and where to do so. I had a couple of schools that I liked and could envision myself at, and Mrs. Finegan really helped me by explaining that my chances at one school—where I looked more like a regular applicant—wouldn’t be hurt if I applied early elsewhere. It’s hard to juggle all the different application options, but she definitely helped me to understand them and make strategic choices.”
Her college counselor also provides necessary doses of reality from time to time, she says, like encouraging her to identify a few more safety schools. “She strikes a really good balance between honesty and compassion,” says Ally. “Mrs. Finegan is very focused on giving me all the facts about the schools I’m looking at and the trends in admission, but then she can also step back and see how all of the information is making me feel. That’s really hard to accomplish in college counseling.”
The ambitious senior is quick to point out that in their frequent meetings, conversation isn’t always just about college. And that, she says, is what makes Pingry’s College Counseling Office feel like a second home.
What would they discuss? Everything from his SAT, ACT, and AP scores to the Common Application to what Pingry class selections would be most beneficial to his desired field of study in college (economics). Mr. Lear also drew up a list of colleges and universities, tailored to Michael’s strengths and interests, that he might wish to visit. Perhaps most appreciated, Michael says, was Mr. Lear’s help with his college essays. “He suggested many edits and corrections and made my essays more personal, more me.”
Michael also cites as very helpful the College Jump Start Program that the College Counseling Office held for rising seniors the week after Commencement. For a full day, 100 students from the Class of 2018 had at their disposal college admissions deans, directors, and representatives from six different schools, all of whom offered insider tips on a variety of topics, from how to write an effective college essay to how to prepare for an admissions interview.
“I don’t know how you can not visit the College Counseling Office,” says Michael, circling back to his mention of visiting Mr. Lear on multiple occasions his junior year. "He has always been so available and provided me so much guidance. I was interested in a particular school and he helped connect me to a Pingry senior who had recently been admitted, as well as an alumnus who graduated from the school.”
Does he envision leaning on the College Counseling Office while he’s in college? “I’ll definitely come back,” he smiles, “if only to thank Mr. Lear for all he has done for me.”
Which is why, when Maddie expressed an interest in public policy (she spent 10 weeks the summer before her senior year interning at the Union County Prosecutor’s Child Advocacy Center), Mrs. Kinney was wholly supportive of the schools she had researched. The veteran college counselor then promptly suggested a handful of others, which she knew had strong programs in the field. In fact, reports Maddie, one of Mrs. Kinney’s suggestions, which she was wary of at first, is now her top choice.
Nervous anticipation is inevitable heading into senior year, especially as the oldest of three children who is paving the way through a seemingly murky endeavor, says Maddie. “My parents and I didn’t know how to navigate the process, but Mrs. Kinney has been there to answer all my questions. Last year, even my dad would email her with the most trivial questions and she would always get back to him! It’s really reassuring to know that someone with so much professional experience is there beside me.”
“I know she had to read about 35 senior autobiographies,” says John (Jake) Patterson ’18, “but she was able to remember and pinpoint random facts about me. She genuinely cares.”
Jake is referring to his college counselor, Mrs. Amy Cooperman. Thanks to that exercise, and talking through his answers with her—in addition to a lengthy discussion about his recent service trip to Costa Rica—Jake says he identified the topic of his Common App essay. What’s more, six pages flowed easily when he returned home that night, so excited and eager was he to start writing.
A thoughtful read of his autobiography isn’t his only compliment of Mrs. Cooperman. “She is the easiest person to talk to. I go into her office for five-minute meeting and we end up sitting and talking for an hour, about all kinds of things,” he adds. “It’s not a relationship that’s solely focused on the college counseling process. It’s a friendship. I always leave her office feeling like I should give her a hug.”
With Mrs. Cooperman’s help, the four-year varsity lacrosse player hopes to pursue an undergraduate program in Business upon graduation from Pingry. Will he be back to visit her? “Definitely,” he smiles.
Holly poured herself into an entirely new sport: crew. And she loved it. “To align boats is to equalize the teams on the starting line before a race. To row is to use your quads, back, shoulders, and hands, leaving the ACL untouched, and unscathed. It is one of the few sports that require no lateral movement. Alignment took on a whole new meaning for me,” she said.
With just two years of competitive club rowing under her belt, and with the support of Pingry’s college counseling department, Holly’s Vanderbilt lacrosse ambitions were seemingly effortlessly transferred to UPenn, where she attends the Wharton School (not surprising, given her role as Student Body President her senior year), and, of course, rows for their women’s crew team.
“Decommiting from Vanderbilt and rediscovering a new sport, one she had no prior experience with, is testament to Holly’s internal drive. That she was offered a spot on the Penn team with such limited experience is amazing, but she more than earned it,” said Pingry’s Director of College Counseling, Mr. Tim Lear.
“Reflecting back on my whole experience, I learned that hard work pays off,” said Holly. “I learned that I am capable of anything I put my mind to, no matter how difficult the situation may seem at first. I learned that I could not have survived the entire college application process without Mr. Lear. I would not trade a single day when I was in the leg brace for another, as I ended up exactly where I am supposed to be. And truthfully, I couldn’t be happier.”
UPDATE: "My freshman year was absolutely amazing! Pingry definitely helped prepare me for the school work, as I felt I knew how to manage my time well. I was also comfortable approaching my professors and reaching out for help when needed. Philly is beautiful, the students and professors are great, and I love being close to home. Over the past year, I rowed on the Penn Women’s Crew Team (and won the Freshman Award and the Most Inspirational Award), I was selected as the Freshmen Representative for Cohort Peso at Wharton, and I joined a sorority. My college counselor, Mr. Lear, and the other staff in the College Counseling Office made the college selection process as easy and as stress-free as possible. I could not thank them enough for their support, patience, and dedication to helping me find the perfect fit."
He tested his dramatic mettle by trying out—and landing a part—in the school musical, Cabaret. He also discovered a knack for throwing shotput, and joined the spring track & field team. Padding his transcript wasn’t necessary; Princeton had already accepted him. But in his 13 years at Pingry, he came to understand that leaving his comfort zone was ok, even smart. “I've learned that I like a lot more than I thought I did; my interests are more diverse than I could have imagined,” he says.
He credits his Pingry college counselor for helping to nurture those interests, giving him honest feedback and clear advice while allowing him to think for himself. He plans to pursue a major of mechanical engineering at Princeton (perhaps double-majoring in astrophysics, if time allows, he says), and a minor in East Asian studies.
With all of his interests, why Princeton?
“The Princeton info session I attended my sophomore year was a typical one. However, the woman who spoke—she graduated from Princeton the year before— stood on stage and gave a 1.5-hour talk without using notes or stuttering once. I was so absolutely floored and impressed by her eloquence, her persona, and her intelligence. I turned to my family and said, ‘If this school can shape me into a young adult like her, I need to go here.’”
UPDATE: "I was lucky to have a college counselor [Mr. Tim Lear] who attended Princeton, and so knew my experience from a first-hand perspective. Over the course of my freshman year, whenever I was in a rut, he offered support and encouragement that was really great to hear. Honestly, my freshman year was such a great experience. I 100% feel like Princeton was a great fit, and I know that I have met lifelong friends and will continue to do so for the next three years. For that reason I’m extremely grateful that Pingry's College Counseling Department, and Mr. Lear, took such care in the process. I really do feel at home here, and they all played a big role in helping me to find this home."
During his senior year, the month of November was tough, he recalled. He had applied early to Haverford, but continued to work on supplemental essays for close to a dozen other schools until he heard final word. “I was pretty stressed and having a bad day," Jamie recalled. “I went to Mr. Lear to talk about one of the essays I was struggling with. He reassured me that it was good, that he was confident in my chances at Haverford. He just helped to calm me down. As both my coach and my college counselor, I relied on him a lot. He was always there for me.”
And Mr. Lear will no doubt follow Jamie’s progress at Haverford, both in the classroom and in races. Like Pingry, Haverford is an honor code school (students reaffirm it annually), which, Jamie says, made it stand out. From his very first visit, he felt comfortable. “I really liked the notion of going to an honor code school, where the students all made a conscious choice to attend, and to stick to it.” When Jamie arrives on campus, he will bring with him all he learned at Pingry—lessons of honor, hard work, sport, and friendship.
UPDATE: "My first year at Haverford was great. A lot of the values and practices I learned at Pingry prepared me really well for college academic life (such as being comfortable approaching professors and going out of my way to ask for help if needed, just to name a couple). Looking back, I am so grateful for Mr. Lear's advising during my college process. Throughout the fall of my senior year, Mr. Lear was candid, open, and honest when we discussed schools, and did not hesitate to steer me towards schools he thought might be a good fit. He and I have stayed in contact since I graduated. It's always great to get an email from him, especially when we talk about running. I really appreciate the fact that he is legitimately interested in how my academic and athletic careers have been since leaving Pingry, and I always enjoy discussing both my classes and my training with him. Mr. Lear is the reason I first found out about Haverford, and I can't thank him enough for that."
Her instincts were right. The unedited version caught Dartmouth’s attention, and now, she’s a happy New Englander, pursuing a subject that has long been of interest to her: neuroscience. Helping to nurture that interest was Ms. Torres’s AP Anatomy and Physiology class, which, as a freshman, Nia had heard Pingry upperclassmen exclaim over. “I heard intriguing things about getting to sit in on surgeries and having the opportunity to participate in several dissections, and I knew it was the class for me. It was everything I expected!” she raved. “I definitely tried to take advantage of the opportunities that Pingry gives its students, doing my best to participate in anything having to do with biology or neuroscience, and Ms. Torres’s class was just one of those opportunities.” Thanks to the patient guidance of college counselor Mrs. Ananya Chatterji—“she helped me to stay as calm and organized as possible”—Nia is now diving deeper into the sciences at a college she feels is the perfect fit.
“Pingry’s college counseling office is amazing and so helpful. Their patience and firm guidance helped me keep a level head during some of the most stressful months of my life,” she said.
Her advice to seniors? Perhaps alluding to her penchant for human sciences, “Stay organized, hydrated, and well-rested. Those three things are key.”